From bc2d3f1e2a2793c7a55d1671a2ddd344780136d2 Mon Sep 17 00:00:00 2001 From: Ralph Amissah Date: Tue, 21 Apr 2026 14:16:00 -0400 Subject: rename .sda references and files to .ssp Rename file extension from .sda to .ssp throughout the format specification and example files. - example-autonomous-contract.sda -> .ssp - example-wealth-of-networks.sda -> .ssp - format-specification.md: all .sda references updated Co-Authored-By: Anthropic Claude Opus 4.6 (1M context) --- example-autonomous-contract.sda | 374 ------------------- example-autonomous-contract.ssp | 374 +++++++++++++++++++ example-wealth-of-networks.sda | 807 ---------------------------------------- example-wealth-of-networks.ssp | 807 ++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++++ format-specification.md | 6 +- 5 files changed, 1184 insertions(+), 1184 deletions(-) delete mode 100644 example-autonomous-contract.sda create mode 100644 example-autonomous-contract.ssp delete mode 100644 example-wealth-of-networks.sda create mode 100644 example-wealth-of-networks.ssp diff --git a/example-autonomous-contract.sda b/example-autonomous-contract.sda deleted file mode 100644 index e306a78..0000000 --- a/example-autonomous-contract.sda +++ /dev/null @@ -1,374 +0,0 @@ -% SiSU Document Abstraction v0.1 -% Source: the_autonomous_contract.ralph_amissah.sst -% Note: hand-crafted example showing what the serialized abstraction -% would look like. The text shown approximates the internal Unicode -% markers that spineAbstraction would produce. - -@meta { - title.main: The Autonomous Contract - title.subtitle: Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting - title.full: The Autonomous Contract: Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting - creator.author: Amissah, Ralph - creator.author_surname: Amissah - creator.author_surname_fn: Amissah, Ralph - date.published: 1997-10-07 - rights.copyright: 1997 Ralph Amissah - classify.topic_register: SiSU markup sample:article:law;law:international:commercial arbitration|uniform law|harmonization - classify.subject: international contracts, international commercial arbitration, private international law - language.document: en - notes.summary: International commercial law writing on the implications of harmonization of law, globalization and international contracting. -} - -@make { - doc_type: article - auto_num_top_at_level: 1 - auto_num_depth: 2 -} - -@doc_has { - inline_links: 5 - inline_notes_reg: 47 -} - -@toc { - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| The Autonomous Contract - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1. Introduction - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2. In search of autonomy - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.1 The diminishing role of States - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.2 Solutions available within national law - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.2.1 Uniform law and its limitations - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.2.2 Uniform rules and principles - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.2.3 Situation specific standard contracts - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.3 A transnational regulatory order for contracts - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.3.1 International commercial arbitration (ICA) - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 2.3.2 Lex Mercatoria - and its essential link to arbitration - -} - -@body { - -[0] heading :A -.part: frontmatter -.segment: title -| The Autonomous Contract - -[0] heading :B -.part: frontmatter -| Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting - -[1] heading :1 intro -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.last_descendant: 6 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 -.segment: intro -| Introduction - -[2] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -.indent: 1 0 -.has: notes_reg -| \u201cGlobalization is unstoppable. Even though it may be only in its -| early stages, it is already intrinsic to the world economy. We have to -| live with it, recognize its advantages and learn to manage it. - -[3] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -.indent: 1 0 -.has: notes_reg -| That imperative applies to governments, who would be unwise to attempt -| to stem the tide for reasons of political expediency. It also goes for -| companies of all sizes, who must now compete on global markets and learn -| to adjust their strategies accordingly, seizing the opportunities that -| globalization offers.\u201d【1 Maria Livanos Cattaui, ⑆/The global -| economy - an opportunity to be seized⑆/ in ⑆/Business World⑆/ the -| Electronic magazine of the International Chamber of Commerce (Paris, -| July 1997) at ┤http://www.iccwbo.org/html/globalec.htm├】 - -[4] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -.has: links notes_reg -| At a national level, jurists as lawmakers over time magically create -| their own reality, that is, the world in which they work, and are -| certified as oracles.【2 Tangential support for the simile from Hans -| Petter Graver, ⑆/\u201cDen juristskapte virkeligheten og -| juristrollen\u201d⑆/ in Jussens Venner (1986) p. 314-324.】 They are -| proud of their traditions in which they are specialists and about which -| they tend to be protective. - -[5] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -.has: notes_reg -| ⑆_The autonomous contract⑆_ is a concept based on three ideas, that -| provide lenses or perspectives with which to view the needs of the -| international business community as they affect and are affected by a -| polymorphous set of interrelated issues and areas of law: ⑆*(i)⑆* -| ⑆/⑆_The \u201cautonomous contract\u201d as an expression of the will -| that \u201cgoverns\u201d international commerce⑆_⑆/. - -[6] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| The practicability and utility of an \u201cautonomous contract\u201d -| (e.g. one founded in a-national law) is dependent on its ability to -| serve the international business community as a suitable risk management -| tool and to result in improved transaction costs. - -[7] heading :1 -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.last_descendant: 20 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 -| In search of autonomy - -[8] para -.part: body -.parent: 7 -| The business community engaged in international commerce has had to find -| ways to cope with the high degree of legal uncertainty brought about by -| the crossing of numerous legal systems whose rules are expressed in a -| multitude of languages. - -[9] para -.part: body -.parent: 7 -.has: notes_reg -| ⑆*(1.a)⑆* Use of standard contracts. ⑆*(1.b)⑆* Reference to uniform -| principles and rules. ⑆*(2.a)⑆* Choice of law of an acceptable -| state.【5 Criteria for selection might include: familiarity; application -| of uniform law; neutrality; reputation; language; and convenience.】 - -[10] para -.part: body -.parent: 7 -| The contract is a formal tool used by the business community to -| structure their relations, for which business practice and economics -| suggest the importance of a predictable and efficient underlying legal -| framework. - -[11] heading :2 -.part: body -.parent: 7 -.last_descendant: 14 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 11 0 0 -| The diminishing role of States - -[12] para -.part: body -.parent: 11 -.has: notes_reg -| The paradigmatic concept of law and model of legal order is still that -| of the sovereign state.【8 E.g. Thomas Wilhelmsson, ⑆/Legal Integration -| as Disintegration of National Law⑆/ in ⑆/Legal Polycentricity - -| Consequences of Pluralism in Law⑆/ (1995) pp. 127-147 on p. 128.】 - -[13] heading :2 -.part: body -.parent: 7 -.last_descendant: 18 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 0 0 -| Solutions available within national law - -[14] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 13 -.last_descendant: 15 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 14 0 -| Uniform law and its limitations - -[15] para -.part: body -.parent: 14 -.has: notes_reg -| Selection of the law of a municipal system that applies uniform law is -| one important step that can be taken within the framework of municipal -| law, to make the contract more autonomous.【10 Regional efforts with -| their frequently associated political objectives are outside the scope -| of this paper.】 - -[16] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 13 -.last_descendant: 17 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 16 0 -| Uniform rules and principles - -[17] para -.part: body -.parent: 16 -.has: notes_reg -| We include in this category, rules and principles governing specific -| aspects of the contractual relationship,【12 E.g. ⑆/ICC's Incoterms⑆/ -| (1990) and contract clauses on ⑆/Hardship and Force Majeure⑆/.】 - -[18] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 13 -.last_descendant: 19 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 18 0 -| Situation specific standard contracts - -[19] para -.part: body -.parent: 18 -| Standard contracts may attempt to be autonomous in themselves, but -| seldom are, having a limited scope of regulation and depending for their -| ultimate interpretation and gap filling on the applicable \u201claw\u201d. - -[20] heading :2 -.part: body -.parent: 7 -.last_descendant: 30 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 20 0 0 -| A transnational regulatory order for contracts - -[21] para -.part: body -.parent: 20 -| Within the traditional municipal order a limited degree of autonomy is -| available in contract. - -[22] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 20 -.last_descendant: 25 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 20 22 0 -| International commercial arbitration (ICA) - -[23] para -.part: body -.parent: 22 -.has: notes_reg -| It appears accepted that ICA has become the most prevalent means of -| dispute resolution in international commerce.【15 Alexander Komarov -| ⑆/Remarks on the Applications of the UNIDROIT Principles⑆/...】 - -[24] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 20 -.last_descendant: 30 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 20 24 0 -| Lex Mercatoria - and its essential link to arbitration - -[25] para -.part: body -.parent: 24 -.indent: 1 0 -.has: notes_reg -| \u201cThe ⑆/lex mercatoria⑆/ has sufficient intellectual credentials -| to merit serious study, and yet is not so generally accepted as to -| escape the sceptical eye.\u201d【20 The Rt. Hon. Lord Justice Mustill, -| ⑆/The New Lex Mercatoria: The First Twenty-five Years⑆/...】 - -} - -@endnotes { - -[0] endnote -.parent: 3 -| 【1 Maria Livanos Cattaui, ⑆/The global economy - an opportunity to be -| seized⑆/ in ⑆/Business World⑆/ the Electronic magazine of the -| International Chamber of Commerce (Paris, July 1997) at -| ┤http://www.iccwbo.org/html/globalec.htm├】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 4 -| 【2 Tangential support for the simile from Hans Petter Graver, -| ⑆/\u201cDen juristskapte virkeligheten og juristrollen\u201d⑆/ in -| Jussens Venner (1986) p. 314-324.】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 4 -| 【3 Rene David suggests the primary constraints on development are -| \u201cconservatism, routine, prejudice and inertia\u201d...】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 9 -| 【5 Criteria for selection might include: familiarity; application of -| uniform law; neutrality; reputation; language; and convenience.】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 12 -| 【8 E.g. Thomas Wilhelmsson, ⑆/Legal Integration as Disintegration of -| National Law⑆/ in ⑆/Legal Polycentricity - Consequences of Pluralism in -| Law⑆/ (1995) pp. 127-147 on p. 128.】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 15 -| 【10 Regional efforts with their frequently associated political -| objectives are outside the scope of this paper.】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 17 -| 【12 E.g. ⑆/ICC's Incoterms⑆/ (1990) and contract clauses on -| ⑆/Hardship and Force Majeure⑆/.】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 23 -| 【15 Alexander Komarov ⑆/Remarks on the Applications of the UNIDROIT -| Principles of International Commercial Contracts in International -| Commercial Arbitration⑆/ (1995) in ⑆/UNIDROIT Principles: A New Lex -| Mercatoria?⑆/ pp. 157-166 on p. 157.】 - -[0] endnote -.parent: 25 -| 【20 The Rt. Hon. Lord Justice Mustill, ⑆/The New Lex Mercatoria: The -| First Twenty-five Years⑆/ in Maarten Bos and Ian Brownlie, Liber -| Amicorum for the Rt. Hon. Lord Wilberforce, Clarendon Press (Oxford, -| 1987) pp.149-183.】 - -} - diff --git a/example-autonomous-contract.ssp b/example-autonomous-contract.ssp new file mode 100644 index 0000000..e306a78 --- /dev/null +++ b/example-autonomous-contract.ssp @@ -0,0 +1,374 @@ +% SiSU Document Abstraction v0.1 +% Source: the_autonomous_contract.ralph_amissah.sst +% Note: hand-crafted example showing what the serialized abstraction +% would look like. The text shown approximates the internal Unicode +% markers that spineAbstraction would produce. + +@meta { + title.main: The Autonomous Contract + title.subtitle: Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting + title.full: The Autonomous Contract: Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting + creator.author: Amissah, Ralph + creator.author_surname: Amissah + creator.author_surname_fn: Amissah, Ralph + date.published: 1997-10-07 + rights.copyright: 1997 Ralph Amissah + classify.topic_register: SiSU markup sample:article:law;law:international:commercial arbitration|uniform law|harmonization + classify.subject: international contracts, international commercial arbitration, private international law + language.document: en + notes.summary: International commercial law writing on the implications of harmonization of law, globalization and international contracting. +} + +@make { + doc_type: article + auto_num_top_at_level: 1 + auto_num_depth: 2 +} + +@doc_has { + inline_links: 5 + inline_notes_reg: 47 +} + +@toc { + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| The Autonomous Contract + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1. Introduction + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2. In search of autonomy + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.1 The diminishing role of States + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.2 Solutions available within national law + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.2.1 Uniform law and its limitations + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.2.2 Uniform rules and principles + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.2.3 Situation specific standard contracts + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.3 A transnational regulatory order for contracts + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.3.1 International commercial arbitration (ICA) + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 2.3.2 Lex Mercatoria - and its essential link to arbitration + +} + +@body { + +[0] heading :A +.part: frontmatter +.segment: title +| The Autonomous Contract + +[0] heading :B +.part: frontmatter +| Reflecting the borderless electronic-commercial environment in contracting + +[1] heading :1 intro +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.last_descendant: 6 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 +.segment: intro +| Introduction + +[2] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +.indent: 1 0 +.has: notes_reg +| \u201cGlobalization is unstoppable. Even though it may be only in its +| early stages, it is already intrinsic to the world economy. We have to +| live with it, recognize its advantages and learn to manage it. + +[3] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +.indent: 1 0 +.has: notes_reg +| That imperative applies to governments, who would be unwise to attempt +| to stem the tide for reasons of political expediency. It also goes for +| companies of all sizes, who must now compete on global markets and learn +| to adjust their strategies accordingly, seizing the opportunities that +| globalization offers.\u201d【1 Maria Livanos Cattaui, ⑆/The global +| economy - an opportunity to be seized⑆/ in ⑆/Business World⑆/ the +| Electronic magazine of the International Chamber of Commerce (Paris, +| July 1997) at ┤http://www.iccwbo.org/html/globalec.htm├】 + +[4] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +.has: links notes_reg +| At a national level, jurists as lawmakers over time magically create +| their own reality, that is, the world in which they work, and are +| certified as oracles.【2 Tangential support for the simile from Hans +| Petter Graver, ⑆/\u201cDen juristskapte virkeligheten og +| juristrollen\u201d⑆/ in Jussens Venner (1986) p. 314-324.】 They are +| proud of their traditions in which they are specialists and about which +| they tend to be protective. + +[5] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +.has: notes_reg +| ⑆_The autonomous contract⑆_ is a concept based on three ideas, that +| provide lenses or perspectives with which to view the needs of the +| international business community as they affect and are affected by a +| polymorphous set of interrelated issues and areas of law: ⑆*(i)⑆* +| ⑆/⑆_The \u201cautonomous contract\u201d as an expression of the will +| that \u201cgoverns\u201d international commerce⑆_⑆/. + +[6] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| The practicability and utility of an \u201cautonomous contract\u201d +| (e.g. one founded in a-national law) is dependent on its ability to +| serve the international business community as a suitable risk management +| tool and to result in improved transaction costs. + +[7] heading :1 +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.last_descendant: 20 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 0 0 0 +| In search of autonomy + +[8] para +.part: body +.parent: 7 +| The business community engaged in international commerce has had to find +| ways to cope with the high degree of legal uncertainty brought about by +| the crossing of numerous legal systems whose rules are expressed in a +| multitude of languages. + +[9] para +.part: body +.parent: 7 +.has: notes_reg +| ⑆*(1.a)⑆* Use of standard contracts. ⑆*(1.b)⑆* Reference to uniform +| principles and rules. ⑆*(2.a)⑆* Choice of law of an acceptable +| state.【5 Criteria for selection might include: familiarity; application +| of uniform law; neutrality; reputation; language; and convenience.】 + +[10] para +.part: body +.parent: 7 +| The contract is a formal tool used by the business community to +| structure their relations, for which business practice and economics +| suggest the importance of a predictable and efficient underlying legal +| framework. + +[11] heading :2 +.part: body +.parent: 7 +.last_descendant: 14 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 11 0 0 +| The diminishing role of States + +[12] para +.part: body +.parent: 11 +.has: notes_reg +| The paradigmatic concept of law and model of legal order is still that +| of the sovereign state.【8 E.g. Thomas Wilhelmsson, ⑆/Legal Integration +| as Disintegration of National Law⑆/ in ⑆/Legal Polycentricity - +| Consequences of Pluralism in Law⑆/ (1995) pp. 127-147 on p. 128.】 + +[13] heading :2 +.part: body +.parent: 7 +.last_descendant: 18 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 0 0 +| Solutions available within national law + +[14] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 13 +.last_descendant: 15 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 14 0 +| Uniform law and its limitations + +[15] para +.part: body +.parent: 14 +.has: notes_reg +| Selection of the law of a municipal system that applies uniform law is +| one important step that can be taken within the framework of municipal +| law, to make the contract more autonomous.【10 Regional efforts with +| their frequently associated political objectives are outside the scope +| of this paper.】 + +[16] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 13 +.last_descendant: 17 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 16 0 +| Uniform rules and principles + +[17] para +.part: body +.parent: 16 +.has: notes_reg +| We include in this category, rules and principles governing specific +| aspects of the contractual relationship,【12 E.g. ⑆/ICC's Incoterms⑆/ +| (1990) and contract clauses on ⑆/Hardship and Force Majeure⑆/.】 + +[18] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 13 +.last_descendant: 19 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 13 18 0 +| Situation specific standard contracts + +[19] para +.part: body +.parent: 18 +| Standard contracts may attempt to be autonomous in themselves, but +| seldom are, having a limited scope of regulation and depending for their +| ultimate interpretation and gap filling on the applicable \u201claw\u201d. + +[20] heading :2 +.part: body +.parent: 7 +.last_descendant: 30 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 20 0 0 +| A transnational regulatory order for contracts + +[21] para +.part: body +.parent: 20 +| Within the traditional municipal order a limited degree of autonomy is +| available in contract. + +[22] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 20 +.last_descendant: 25 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 20 22 0 +| International commercial arbitration (ICA) + +[23] para +.part: body +.parent: 22 +.has: notes_reg +| It appears accepted that ICA has become the most prevalent means of +| dispute resolution in international commerce.【15 Alexander Komarov +| ⑆/Remarks on the Applications of the UNIDROIT Principles⑆/...】 + +[24] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 20 +.last_descendant: 30 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 7 20 24 0 +| Lex Mercatoria - and its essential link to arbitration + +[25] para +.part: body +.parent: 24 +.indent: 1 0 +.has: notes_reg +| \u201cThe ⑆/lex mercatoria⑆/ has sufficient intellectual credentials +| to merit serious study, and yet is not so generally accepted as to +| escape the sceptical eye.\u201d【20 The Rt. Hon. Lord Justice Mustill, +| ⑆/The New Lex Mercatoria: The First Twenty-five Years⑆/...】 + +} + +@endnotes { + +[0] endnote +.parent: 3 +| 【1 Maria Livanos Cattaui, ⑆/The global economy - an opportunity to be +| seized⑆/ in ⑆/Business World⑆/ the Electronic magazine of the +| International Chamber of Commerce (Paris, July 1997) at +| ┤http://www.iccwbo.org/html/globalec.htm├】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 4 +| 【2 Tangential support for the simile from Hans Petter Graver, +| ⑆/\u201cDen juristskapte virkeligheten og juristrollen\u201d⑆/ in +| Jussens Venner (1986) p. 314-324.】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 4 +| 【3 Rene David suggests the primary constraints on development are +| \u201cconservatism, routine, prejudice and inertia\u201d...】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 9 +| 【5 Criteria for selection might include: familiarity; application of +| uniform law; neutrality; reputation; language; and convenience.】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 12 +| 【8 E.g. Thomas Wilhelmsson, ⑆/Legal Integration as Disintegration of +| National Law⑆/ in ⑆/Legal Polycentricity - Consequences of Pluralism in +| Law⑆/ (1995) pp. 127-147 on p. 128.】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 15 +| 【10 Regional efforts with their frequently associated political +| objectives are outside the scope of this paper.】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 17 +| 【12 E.g. ⑆/ICC's Incoterms⑆/ (1990) and contract clauses on +| ⑆/Hardship and Force Majeure⑆/.】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 23 +| 【15 Alexander Komarov ⑆/Remarks on the Applications of the UNIDROIT +| Principles of International Commercial Contracts in International +| Commercial Arbitration⑆/ (1995) in ⑆/UNIDROIT Principles: A New Lex +| Mercatoria?⑆/ pp. 157-166 on p. 157.】 + +[0] endnote +.parent: 25 +| 【20 The Rt. Hon. Lord Justice Mustill, ⑆/The New Lex Mercatoria: The +| First Twenty-five Years⑆/ in Maarten Bos and Ian Brownlie, Liber +| Amicorum for the Rt. Hon. Lord Wilberforce, Clarendon Press (Oxford, +| 1987) pp.149-183.】 + +} + diff --git a/example-wealth-of-networks.sda b/example-wealth-of-networks.sda deleted file mode 100644 index 2bf48bb..0000000 --- a/example-wealth-of-networks.sda +++ /dev/null @@ -1,807 +0,0 @@ -% SiSU Document Abstraction v0.1 -% Source: the_wealth_of_networks.yochai_benkler.sst -% Hand-crafted example showing what the serialized abstraction would -% look like. Covers document preamble through Chapter 1 (~first 280 -% lines of a 5833-line source). -% Text approximates the internal Unicode markers that spineAbstraction -% produces. OCN values are illustrative - actual values depend on the -% full document processing. - -@meta { - title.main: The Wealth of Networks - title.subtitle: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom - title.full: The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom - title.language: US - creator.author: Benkler, Yochai - creator.author_surname: Benkler - creator.author_surname_fn: Benkler, Yochai - date.published: 2006-04-03 - date.created: 2006-04-03 - date.issued: 2006-04-03 - date.available: 2006-04-03 - date.modified: 2006-04-03 - date.valid: 2006-04-03 - rights.copyright: 2006 Yochai Benkler. - rights.license: All rights reserved. Subject to the exception immediately following, this book may not be reproduced...Creative Commons Noncommercial Sharealike license - classify.topic_register: SiSU markup sample:book:discourse;networks;Internet;intellectual property:patents|copyright;intellectual property:copyright:creative commons;economics;society;copyright;patents;book:subject:information society|information networks|economics|public policy|society|copyright|patents - identifier.isbn: 9780300110562 - identifier.oclc: 61881089 - language.document: en -} - -@make { - doc_type: book - breaks: new=:B; break=1 -} - -@doc_has { - inline_links: 342 - inline_notes_reg: 891 - tables: 3 -} - -@toc { - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| The Wealth of Networks - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| Attribution - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| Acknowledgments - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1. Chapter 1 - Introduction: A Moment of Opportunity and Challenge - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1.1 THE EMERGENCE OF THE NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1.2 NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY AND LIBERAL, DEMOCRATIC SOCIETIES - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1.2.1 Enhanced Autonomy - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1.2.2 Democracy: The Networked Public Sphere - -[0] toc -.part: frontmatter -.section: toc -| 1.2.3 Justice and Human Development - -} - -@body { - -% ---- Document root ---- - -[0] heading :A -.part: frontmatter -.segment: title -| The Wealth of Networks┙Benkler, Yochai - -% ---- OCN suppressed region (--~# to --+#) ---- - -[0] heading :1 attribution -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.last_descendant: 4 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 -.segment: attribution -.ocn_off: true -| Attribution - -[0] para -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.ocn_off: true -| ⑆!For Deb, Noam, and Ari⑆! - -[0] para -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.ocn_off: true -| \u201cHuman nature is not a machine to be built after a model, and set -| to do exactly the work prescribed for it, but a tree, which requires -| to grow and develop itself on all sides, according to the tendency of -| the inward forces which make it a living thing.\u201d \u201cSuch are -| the differences among human beings in their sources of pleasure, their -| susceptibilities of pain, and the operation on them of different -| physical and moral agencies, that unless there is a corresponding -| diversity in their modes of life, they neither obtain their fair share -| of happiness, nor grow up to the mental, moral, and aesthetic stature -| of which their nature is capable.\u201d - -[0] para -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.ocn_off: true -| John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859) - -% ---- OCN numbering resumes ---- - -[1] heading :1 acknowledgments -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.last_descendant: 8 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 -.segment: acknowledgments -| Acknowledgments - -[2] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| Reading this manuscript was an act of heroic generosity. I owe my -| gratitude to those who did and who therefore helped me to avoid at -| least some of the errors that I would have made without their -| assistance. Bruce Ackerman spent countless hours listening, and -| reading and challenging both this book and its precursor bits and -| pieces since 2001. I owe much of its present conception and form to -| his friendship. Jack Balkin not only read the manuscript, but in an -| act of great generosity taught it to his seminar, imposed it on the -| fellows of Yale's Information Society Project, and then spent hours -| with me working through the limitations and pitfalls they found. -| ,{[pg 10]}, - -[3] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| This book has been more than a decade in the making. Its roots go back -| to 1993-1994: long nights of conversations, as only graduate students -| can have, with Niva Elkin Koren about democracy in cyberspace; a -| series of formative conversations with Mitch Kapor; a couple of madly -| imaginative sessions with Charlie Nesson; and a moment of true -| understanding with Eben Moglen. - -[4] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| Much of the early work in this project was done at New York -| University, whose law school offered me an intellectually engaging and -| institutionally safe environment to explore some quite unorthodox -| views. -.has: bookindex -={ institutional ecology of digital environment } - -[5] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| Since 2001, first as a visitor and now as a member, I have had the -| remarkable pleasure of being part of the intellectual community that -| is Yale Law School. ,{[pg xii]}, - -[6] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| Oddly enough, I have ⑆*never had the proper context⑆* in which to -| give two more basic thanks. - -[7] para -.part: body -.parent: 1 -| Finally, to my best friend and tag-team partner in this tussle we -| call life, Deborah Schrag, with whom I have shared nicely more or less -| everything since we were barely adults. ,{[pg 1]}, - -% ---- Chapter 1 ---- - -[8] heading :1 -.part: body -.parent: 0 -.last_descendant: 60 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 -.segment: ch1 -| Chapter 1 - Introduction: A Moment of Opportunity and Challenge - -[9] para -.part: body -.parent: 8 -| Information, knowledge, and culture are central to human freedom and -| human development. How they are produced and exchanged in our society -| critically affects the way we see the state of the world as it is and -| might be; who decides these questions; and how we, as societies and -| polities, come to understand what can and ought to be done. ,{[pg 2]}, -.has: bookindex -={ access : - human development and justice +2 ; - information economy +55 -} - -[10] para -.part: body -.parent: 8 -| A series of changes in the technologies, economic organization, and -| social practices of production in this environment has created new -| opportunities for how we make and exchange information, knowledge, and -| culture. These changes have increased the role of nonmarket and -| nonproprietary production, both by individuals alone and by -| cooperative efforts in a wide range of loosely or tightly woven -| collaborations. - -[11] para -.part: body -.parent: 8 -| The rise of greater scope for individual and cooperative nonmarket -| production of information and culture, however, threatens the -| incumbents of the industrial information economy. - -% ---- Section 1.1 ---- - -[12] heading :2 -.part: body -.parent: 8 -.last_descendant: 25 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 12 0 0 -| THE EMERGENCE OF THE NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY -.has: bookindex -={ information economy : - emergence of +9 ; - networked information economy +52 : - emergence of +9 -} - -[13] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| The most advanced economies in the world today have made two parallel -| shifts that, paradoxically, make possible a significant attenuation of -| the limitations that market-based production places on the pursuit of -| the political ,{[pg 3]}, values central to liberal societies. -.has: bookindex -={ nonmarket information producers +4 ; - physical constraints on information production +2 ; - production of information : - physical constraints on +2 -} - -[14] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| The first part of this book is dedicated to establishing a number of -| basic economic observations. Its overarching claim is that we are -| seeing the emergence of a new stage in the information economy, which -| I call the \u201cnetworked information economy.\u201d ,{[pg 4]}, -.has: bookindex -={ capabilities of individuals : - coordinated effects of individual actions ; - commercial model of communication +1 ; - constraints of information production, physical +1 ; - coordinated effects of individual actions +2 ; - individual capabilities and action : - coordinated effects of individual actions +2 ; - industrial model of communication +1 ; - information production : - physical constraints on +1 ; - institutional ecology of digital environment +1 ; - traditional model of communication -} - -[15] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| The removal of the physical constraints on effective information -| production has made human creativity and the economics of information -| itself the core structuring facts in the new networked information -| economy. - -[16] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| Second, we have in fact seen the rise of nonmarket production to much -| greater importance. ,{[pg 5]}, -.has: bookindex -={ aggregate effect of individual action } - -[17] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -.has: bookindex -| Third, and likely most radical, new, and difficult for observers to -| believe, is the rise of effective, large-scale cooperative -| efforts--peer production of information, knowledge, and culture. -={ free software +1 ; - open-source software +1 ; - peer production ; - software, open-source -} - -[18] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -.has: links -| It is easy to miss these changes. They run against the grain of some -| of our most basic Economics 101 intuitions. The undeniable economic -| success of free software has prompted some leading-edge economists to -| try to understand why many thousands of loosely networked free software -| developers can compete with Microsoft at its own game and produce a -| massive operating system--GNU/Linux. Why can fifty thousand volunteers -| successfully coauthor ⑆/Wikipedia⑆/, the most serious online -| alternative to the Encyclopedia Britannica, and then turn around and -| give it away for free? ,{[pg 6]}, -.has: bookindex -={ Moglen, Eben ; - von Hippel, Eric ; - Stallman, Richard -} - -[19] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| Human beings are, and always have been, diversely motivated beings. We -| act instrumentally, but also noninstrumentally. We act for material -| gain, but also for psychological well-being and gratification, and for -| social connectedness. -.has: bookindex -={ behavior : - motivation to produce +2 ; - capital for production +1 ; - constraints of information production, monetary ; - diversity : - human motivation +1 | motivation to produce +1 ; - human motivation ; - incentives to produce ; - information production capital +1 ; - monetary constraints on information production +2 ; - motivation to produce +1 ; - physical capital for production +2 ; - production capital +2 -} - -[20] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| In the networked information economy, the physical capital required -| for production is broadly distributed throughout society. Personal -| computers and network connections are ubiquitous. ,{[pg 7]}, - -[21] para -.part: body -.parent: 12 -| Because the presence and importance of nonmarket production has become -| so counterintuitive to people living in market-based economies at the -| end of the twentieth century, part I of this volume is fairly detailed -| and technical. - -% ---- Section 1.2 ---- - -[22] heading :2 -.part: body -.parent: 8 -.last_descendant: 40 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 0 0 -| NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY AND LIBERAL, DEMOCRATIC SOCIETIES -.has: bookindex -={ democratic societies +15 ; - information economy : - democracy and liberalism +15 ; - liberal societies +15 ; - networked information economy : - democracy and liberalism +15 -} - -[23] para -.part: body -.parent: 22 -| How we make information, how we get it, how we speak to others, and -| how others speak to us are core components of the shape of freedom in -| any society. ,{[pg 8]}, - -% ---- Section 1.2.1 ---- - -[24] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 22 -.last_descendant: 28 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 24 0 -| Enhanced Autonomy -.has: bookindex -={ autonomy +3 ; - individual autonomy +2 ; - democratic societies : - autonomy +3 ; - liberal societies : - autonomy +3 -} - -[25] para -.part: body -.parent: 24 -| The networked information economy improves the practical capacities of -| individuals along three dimensions: (1) it improves their capacity to -| do more for and by themselves; (2) it enhances their capacity to do -| more in loose commonality with others, without being constrained to -| organize their relationship through a price system or in traditional -| hierarchical models of social and economic organization; and (3) it -| improves the capacity of individuals to do more in formal -| organizations that operate outside the market sphere. ,{[pg 9]}, -.has: bookindex -={ institutional ecology of digital environment +1 ; - loose affiliations +1 ; - networked public sphere : - loose affiliations +1 ; - norms (social) : - loose affiliations +1 ; - peer production : - loose affiliations ; - public sphere : - loose affiliations +1 ; - regulation by social norms : - loose affiliations +1 ; - scope of loose relations +1 ; - social relations and norms : - loose affiliations +1 -} - -[26] para -.part: body -.parent: 24 -| I begin, therefore, with an analysis of the effects of networked -| information economy on individual autonomy. First, individuals can do -| more for themselves independently of the permission or cooperation of -| others. - -[27] para -.part: body -.parent: 24 -| These ways in which autonomy is enhanced require a fairly substantive -| and rich conception of autonomy as a practical lived experience, -| rather than the formal conception preferred by many who think of -| autonomy as a philosophical concept. -.has: bookindex -={ commercial model of communication ; - industrial model of communication ; - traditional model of communication -} - -% ---- Section 1.2.2 ---- - -[28] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 22 -.last_descendant: 33 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 28 0 -| Democracy: The Networked Public Sphere -.has: bookindex -={ democratic societies : - public sphere, shift from mass media +4 -} - -[29] para -.part: body -.parent: 28 -| The second major implication of the networked information economy is -| the shift it enables from the mass-mediated public sphere to a -| networked public sphere. ,{[pg 10]}, -.has: bookindex -={ centralization of communications : - decentralization +3 ; - decentralization of communications +3 ; - democratic societies : - shift from mass-media communications model +3 ; - Babel objection ; - commercial model of communication : - shift away from +2 ; - institutional ecology of digital environment : - shift away from +3 ; - networked public sphere +3 ; - public sphere +3 ; - information overload and Babel objection -} - -[30] para -.part: body -.parent: 28 -| In chapters 6 and 7, I offer a detailed and updated analysis of this, -| perhaps the best-known and most contentious claim about the Internet's -| liberalizing effects. ,{[pg 11]}, - -[31] para -.part: body -.parent: 28 -| The empirical and theoretical literature about network topology and -| use provides answers to all the major critiques of the claim that the -| Internet improves the structure of the public sphere. ,{[pg 12]}, -| ,{[pg 13]}, -.has: bookindex -={ accreditation : - as public good ; - Babel objection ; - clusters in network topology ; - information overload and Babel objection ; - filtering : - as public good ; - information flow ; - local clusters in network topology ; - regional clusters in network topology ; - relevance filtering : - as public good -} - -% ---- Section 1.2.3 ---- - -[32] heading :3 -.part: body -.parent: 22 -.last_descendant: 35 -.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 32 0 -| Justice and Human Development -.has: bookindex -={ access : - human development and justice +3 ; - democratic societies : - justice and human development +3 ; - human development and justice +3 ; - justice and human development +3 ; - liberal societies : - justice and human development -} - -[33] para -.part: body -.parent: 32 -| Information, knowledge, and information-rich goods and tools play a -| significant role in economic opportunity and human development. -| ,{[pg 14]}, - -[34] para -.part: body -.parent: 32 -| From a more substantive and global perspective focused on human -| development, the freedom to use basic resources and capabilities -| allows improved participation in the production of information and -| information-dependent components of human development. -.has: bookindex -={ free software : - human development and justice ; - innovation : - human development +1 ; - open-source software : - human development and justice -} - -} - -@endnotes { - -% No endnotes in the Introduction chapter of this document. -% The Acknowledgments and Introduction sections shown above do not -% contain footnotes in the original text. Footnotes begin appearing -% in Chapter 2 and later chapters. - -} - -@bookindex { - -% Generated from ={ } entries throughout the body. -% The bookindex section aggregates all index terms across the document, -% sorted alphabetically, with OCN references collected. - -[0] bookindex -| access -| human development and justice: 9-11, 32-35 - -[0] bookindex -| accreditation -| as public good: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| aggregate effect of individual action: 16 - -[0] bookindex -| autonomy: 24-27 -| individual autonomy: 24-26 - -[0] bookindex -| Babel objection: 29, 31 - -[0] bookindex -| behavior -| motivation to produce: 19-21 - -[0] bookindex -| capabilities of individuals -| coordinated effects of individual actions: 14 - -[0] bookindex -| capital for production: 19-20 - -[0] bookindex -| centralization of communications -| decentralization: 29-32 - -[0] bookindex -| clusters in network topology: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| commercial model of communication: 14-15, 27, 29 -| shift away from: 29-31 - -[0] bookindex -| constraints of information production, monetary: 19 -| constraints of information production, physical: 14-15 - -[0] bookindex -| coordinated effects of individual actions: 14-16 - -[0] bookindex -| decentralization of communications: 29-32 - -[0] bookindex -| democratic societies: 22-37 -| autonomy: 24-27 -| justice and human development: 32-35 -| public sphere, shift from mass media: 28-32 -| shift from mass-media communications model: 29-32 - -[0] bookindex -| diversity -| human motivation: 19-20 -| motivation to produce: 19-20 - -[0] bookindex -| filtering -| as public good: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| free software: 17-18 -| human development and justice: 34 - -[0] bookindex -| human development and justice: 32-35 - -[0] bookindex -| human motivation: 19 - -[0] bookindex -| incentives to produce: 19 - -[0] bookindex -| individual capabilities and action -| coordinated effects of individual actions: 14-16 - -[0] bookindex -| industrial model of communication: 14-15, 27 -| shift away from: 29-32 - -[0] bookindex -| information economy: 9-64 -| democracy and liberalism: 22-37 -| emergence of: 12-21 - -[0] bookindex -| information flow: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| information overload and Babel objection: 29, 31 - -[0] bookindex -| information production -| physical constraints on: 14-15 - -[0] bookindex -| information production capital: 19-20 - -[0] bookindex -| innovation -| human development: 34-35 - -[0] bookindex -| institutional ecology of digital environment: 4, 14-15, 25-26 -| shift away from: 29-32 - -[0] bookindex -| justice and human development: 32-35 - -[0] bookindex -| liberal societies: 22-37 -| autonomy: 24-27 -| justice and human development: 32 - -[0] bookindex -| local clusters in network topology: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| loose affiliations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| Moglen, Eben: 18 - -[0] bookindex -| monetary constraints on information production: 19-21 - -[0] bookindex -| motivation to produce: 19-20 - -[0] bookindex -| networked information economy: 12-64 -| democracy and liberalism: 22-37 -| emergence of: 12-21 - -[0] bookindex -| networked public sphere: 29-32 -| loose affiliations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| nonmarket information producers: 13-17 - -[0] bookindex -| norms (social) -| loose affiliations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| open-source software: 17-18 -| human development and justice: 34 - -[0] bookindex -| peer production: 17 -| loose affiliations: 25 - -[0] bookindex -| physical capital for production: 19-21 -| physical constraints on information production: 13-15 - -[0] bookindex -| production capital: 19-21 -| production of information -| physical constraints on: 13-15 - -[0] bookindex -| public sphere: 29-32 -| loose affiliations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| regional clusters in network topology: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| regulation by social norms -| loose affiliations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| relevance filtering -| as public good: 31 - -[0] bookindex -| scope of loose relations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| social relations and norms -| loose affiliations: 25-26 - -[0] bookindex -| software, open-source: 17 - -[0] bookindex -| Stallman, Richard: 18 - -[0] bookindex -| traditional model of communication: 14, 27 -| shift away from: 29-32 - -[0] bookindex -| von Hippel, Eric: 18 - -} - diff --git a/example-wealth-of-networks.ssp b/example-wealth-of-networks.ssp new file mode 100644 index 0000000..2bf48bb --- /dev/null +++ b/example-wealth-of-networks.ssp @@ -0,0 +1,807 @@ +% SiSU Document Abstraction v0.1 +% Source: the_wealth_of_networks.yochai_benkler.sst +% Hand-crafted example showing what the serialized abstraction would +% look like. Covers document preamble through Chapter 1 (~first 280 +% lines of a 5833-line source). +% Text approximates the internal Unicode markers that spineAbstraction +% produces. OCN values are illustrative - actual values depend on the +% full document processing. + +@meta { + title.main: The Wealth of Networks + title.subtitle: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom + title.full: The Wealth of Networks: How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom + title.language: US + creator.author: Benkler, Yochai + creator.author_surname: Benkler + creator.author_surname_fn: Benkler, Yochai + date.published: 2006-04-03 + date.created: 2006-04-03 + date.issued: 2006-04-03 + date.available: 2006-04-03 + date.modified: 2006-04-03 + date.valid: 2006-04-03 + rights.copyright: 2006 Yochai Benkler. + rights.license: All rights reserved. Subject to the exception immediately following, this book may not be reproduced...Creative Commons Noncommercial Sharealike license + classify.topic_register: SiSU markup sample:book:discourse;networks;Internet;intellectual property:patents|copyright;intellectual property:copyright:creative commons;economics;society;copyright;patents;book:subject:information society|information networks|economics|public policy|society|copyright|patents + identifier.isbn: 9780300110562 + identifier.oclc: 61881089 + language.document: en +} + +@make { + doc_type: book + breaks: new=:B; break=1 +} + +@doc_has { + inline_links: 342 + inline_notes_reg: 891 + tables: 3 +} + +@toc { + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| The Wealth of Networks + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| How Social Production Transforms Markets and Freedom + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| Attribution + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| Acknowledgments + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1. Chapter 1 - Introduction: A Moment of Opportunity and Challenge + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1.1 THE EMERGENCE OF THE NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1.2 NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY AND LIBERAL, DEMOCRATIC SOCIETIES + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1.2.1 Enhanced Autonomy + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1.2.2 Democracy: The Networked Public Sphere + +[0] toc +.part: frontmatter +.section: toc +| 1.2.3 Justice and Human Development + +} + +@body { + +% ---- Document root ---- + +[0] heading :A +.part: frontmatter +.segment: title +| The Wealth of Networks┙Benkler, Yochai + +% ---- OCN suppressed region (--~# to --+#) ---- + +[0] heading :1 attribution +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.last_descendant: 4 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 0 +.segment: attribution +.ocn_off: true +| Attribution + +[0] para +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.ocn_off: true +| ⑆!For Deb, Noam, and Ari⑆! + +[0] para +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.ocn_off: true +| \u201cHuman nature is not a machine to be built after a model, and set +| to do exactly the work prescribed for it, but a tree, which requires +| to grow and develop itself on all sides, according to the tendency of +| the inward forces which make it a living thing.\u201d \u201cSuch are +| the differences among human beings in their sources of pleasure, their +| susceptibilities of pain, and the operation on them of different +| physical and moral agencies, that unless there is a corresponding +| diversity in their modes of life, they neither obtain their fair share +| of happiness, nor grow up to the mental, moral, and aesthetic stature +| of which their nature is capable.\u201d + +[0] para +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.ocn_off: true +| John Stuart Mill, On Liberty (1859) + +% ---- OCN numbering resumes ---- + +[1] heading :1 acknowledgments +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.last_descendant: 8 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 1 0 0 0 +.segment: acknowledgments +| Acknowledgments + +[2] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| Reading this manuscript was an act of heroic generosity. I owe my +| gratitude to those who did and who therefore helped me to avoid at +| least some of the errors that I would have made without their +| assistance. Bruce Ackerman spent countless hours listening, and +| reading and challenging both this book and its precursor bits and +| pieces since 2001. I owe much of its present conception and form to +| his friendship. Jack Balkin not only read the manuscript, but in an +| act of great generosity taught it to his seminar, imposed it on the +| fellows of Yale's Information Society Project, and then spent hours +| with me working through the limitations and pitfalls they found. +| ,{[pg 10]}, + +[3] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| This book has been more than a decade in the making. Its roots go back +| to 1993-1994: long nights of conversations, as only graduate students +| can have, with Niva Elkin Koren about democracy in cyberspace; a +| series of formative conversations with Mitch Kapor; a couple of madly +| imaginative sessions with Charlie Nesson; and a moment of true +| understanding with Eben Moglen. + +[4] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| Much of the early work in this project was done at New York +| University, whose law school offered me an intellectually engaging and +| institutionally safe environment to explore some quite unorthodox +| views. +.has: bookindex +={ institutional ecology of digital environment } + +[5] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| Since 2001, first as a visitor and now as a member, I have had the +| remarkable pleasure of being part of the intellectual community that +| is Yale Law School. ,{[pg xii]}, + +[6] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| Oddly enough, I have ⑆*never had the proper context⑆* in which to +| give two more basic thanks. + +[7] para +.part: body +.parent: 1 +| Finally, to my best friend and tag-team partner in this tussle we +| call life, Deborah Schrag, with whom I have shared nicely more or less +| everything since we were barely adults. ,{[pg 1]}, + +% ---- Chapter 1 ---- + +[8] heading :1 +.part: body +.parent: 0 +.last_descendant: 60 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 0 0 0 +.segment: ch1 +| Chapter 1 - Introduction: A Moment of Opportunity and Challenge + +[9] para +.part: body +.parent: 8 +| Information, knowledge, and culture are central to human freedom and +| human development. How they are produced and exchanged in our society +| critically affects the way we see the state of the world as it is and +| might be; who decides these questions; and how we, as societies and +| polities, come to understand what can and ought to be done. ,{[pg 2]}, +.has: bookindex +={ access : + human development and justice +2 ; + information economy +55 +} + +[10] para +.part: body +.parent: 8 +| A series of changes in the technologies, economic organization, and +| social practices of production in this environment has created new +| opportunities for how we make and exchange information, knowledge, and +| culture. These changes have increased the role of nonmarket and +| nonproprietary production, both by individuals alone and by +| cooperative efforts in a wide range of loosely or tightly woven +| collaborations. + +[11] para +.part: body +.parent: 8 +| The rise of greater scope for individual and cooperative nonmarket +| production of information and culture, however, threatens the +| incumbents of the industrial information economy. + +% ---- Section 1.1 ---- + +[12] heading :2 +.part: body +.parent: 8 +.last_descendant: 25 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 12 0 0 +| THE EMERGENCE OF THE NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY +.has: bookindex +={ information economy : + emergence of +9 ; + networked information economy +52 : + emergence of +9 +} + +[13] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| The most advanced economies in the world today have made two parallel +| shifts that, paradoxically, make possible a significant attenuation of +| the limitations that market-based production places on the pursuit of +| the political ,{[pg 3]}, values central to liberal societies. +.has: bookindex +={ nonmarket information producers +4 ; + physical constraints on information production +2 ; + production of information : + physical constraints on +2 +} + +[14] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| The first part of this book is dedicated to establishing a number of +| basic economic observations. Its overarching claim is that we are +| seeing the emergence of a new stage in the information economy, which +| I call the \u201cnetworked information economy.\u201d ,{[pg 4]}, +.has: bookindex +={ capabilities of individuals : + coordinated effects of individual actions ; + commercial model of communication +1 ; + constraints of information production, physical +1 ; + coordinated effects of individual actions +2 ; + individual capabilities and action : + coordinated effects of individual actions +2 ; + industrial model of communication +1 ; + information production : + physical constraints on +1 ; + institutional ecology of digital environment +1 ; + traditional model of communication +} + +[15] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| The removal of the physical constraints on effective information +| production has made human creativity and the economics of information +| itself the core structuring facts in the new networked information +| economy. + +[16] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| Second, we have in fact seen the rise of nonmarket production to much +| greater importance. ,{[pg 5]}, +.has: bookindex +={ aggregate effect of individual action } + +[17] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +.has: bookindex +| Third, and likely most radical, new, and difficult for observers to +| believe, is the rise of effective, large-scale cooperative +| efforts--peer production of information, knowledge, and culture. +={ free software +1 ; + open-source software +1 ; + peer production ; + software, open-source +} + +[18] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +.has: links +| It is easy to miss these changes. They run against the grain of some +| of our most basic Economics 101 intuitions. The undeniable economic +| success of free software has prompted some leading-edge economists to +| try to understand why many thousands of loosely networked free software +| developers can compete with Microsoft at its own game and produce a +| massive operating system--GNU/Linux. Why can fifty thousand volunteers +| successfully coauthor ⑆/Wikipedia⑆/, the most serious online +| alternative to the Encyclopedia Britannica, and then turn around and +| give it away for free? ,{[pg 6]}, +.has: bookindex +={ Moglen, Eben ; + von Hippel, Eric ; + Stallman, Richard +} + +[19] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| Human beings are, and always have been, diversely motivated beings. We +| act instrumentally, but also noninstrumentally. We act for material +| gain, but also for psychological well-being and gratification, and for +| social connectedness. +.has: bookindex +={ behavior : + motivation to produce +2 ; + capital for production +1 ; + constraints of information production, monetary ; + diversity : + human motivation +1 | motivation to produce +1 ; + human motivation ; + incentives to produce ; + information production capital +1 ; + monetary constraints on information production +2 ; + motivation to produce +1 ; + physical capital for production +2 ; + production capital +2 +} + +[20] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| In the networked information economy, the physical capital required +| for production is broadly distributed throughout society. Personal +| computers and network connections are ubiquitous. ,{[pg 7]}, + +[21] para +.part: body +.parent: 12 +| Because the presence and importance of nonmarket production has become +| so counterintuitive to people living in market-based economies at the +| end of the twentieth century, part I of this volume is fairly detailed +| and technical. + +% ---- Section 1.2 ---- + +[22] heading :2 +.part: body +.parent: 8 +.last_descendant: 40 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 0 0 +| NETWORKED INFORMATION ECONOMY AND LIBERAL, DEMOCRATIC SOCIETIES +.has: bookindex +={ democratic societies +15 ; + information economy : + democracy and liberalism +15 ; + liberal societies +15 ; + networked information economy : + democracy and liberalism +15 +} + +[23] para +.part: body +.parent: 22 +| How we make information, how we get it, how we speak to others, and +| how others speak to us are core components of the shape of freedom in +| any society. ,{[pg 8]}, + +% ---- Section 1.2.1 ---- + +[24] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 22 +.last_descendant: 28 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 24 0 +| Enhanced Autonomy +.has: bookindex +={ autonomy +3 ; + individual autonomy +2 ; + democratic societies : + autonomy +3 ; + liberal societies : + autonomy +3 +} + +[25] para +.part: body +.parent: 24 +| The networked information economy improves the practical capacities of +| individuals along three dimensions: (1) it improves their capacity to +| do more for and by themselves; (2) it enhances their capacity to do +| more in loose commonality with others, without being constrained to +| organize their relationship through a price system or in traditional +| hierarchical models of social and economic organization; and (3) it +| improves the capacity of individuals to do more in formal +| organizations that operate outside the market sphere. ,{[pg 9]}, +.has: bookindex +={ institutional ecology of digital environment +1 ; + loose affiliations +1 ; + networked public sphere : + loose affiliations +1 ; + norms (social) : + loose affiliations +1 ; + peer production : + loose affiliations ; + public sphere : + loose affiliations +1 ; + regulation by social norms : + loose affiliations +1 ; + scope of loose relations +1 ; + social relations and norms : + loose affiliations +1 +} + +[26] para +.part: body +.parent: 24 +| I begin, therefore, with an analysis of the effects of networked +| information economy on individual autonomy. First, individuals can do +| more for themselves independently of the permission or cooperation of +| others. + +[27] para +.part: body +.parent: 24 +| These ways in which autonomy is enhanced require a fairly substantive +| and rich conception of autonomy as a practical lived experience, +| rather than the formal conception preferred by many who think of +| autonomy as a philosophical concept. +.has: bookindex +={ commercial model of communication ; + industrial model of communication ; + traditional model of communication +} + +% ---- Section 1.2.2 ---- + +[28] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 22 +.last_descendant: 33 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 28 0 +| Democracy: The Networked Public Sphere +.has: bookindex +={ democratic societies : + public sphere, shift from mass media +4 +} + +[29] para +.part: body +.parent: 28 +| The second major implication of the networked information economy is +| the shift it enables from the mass-mediated public sphere to a +| networked public sphere. ,{[pg 10]}, +.has: bookindex +={ centralization of communications : + decentralization +3 ; + decentralization of communications +3 ; + democratic societies : + shift from mass-media communications model +3 ; + Babel objection ; + commercial model of communication : + shift away from +2 ; + institutional ecology of digital environment : + shift away from +3 ; + networked public sphere +3 ; + public sphere +3 ; + information overload and Babel objection +} + +[30] para +.part: body +.parent: 28 +| In chapters 6 and 7, I offer a detailed and updated analysis of this, +| perhaps the best-known and most contentious claim about the Internet's +| liberalizing effects. ,{[pg 11]}, + +[31] para +.part: body +.parent: 28 +| The empirical and theoretical literature about network topology and +| use provides answers to all the major critiques of the claim that the +| Internet improves the structure of the public sphere. ,{[pg 12]}, +| ,{[pg 13]}, +.has: bookindex +={ accreditation : + as public good ; + Babel objection ; + clusters in network topology ; + information overload and Babel objection ; + filtering : + as public good ; + information flow ; + local clusters in network topology ; + regional clusters in network topology ; + relevance filtering : + as public good +} + +% ---- Section 1.2.3 ---- + +[32] heading :3 +.part: body +.parent: 22 +.last_descendant: 35 +.ancestors: 0 0 0 0 8 22 32 0 +| Justice and Human Development +.has: bookindex +={ access : + human development and justice +3 ; + democratic societies : + justice and human development +3 ; + human development and justice +3 ; + justice and human development +3 ; + liberal societies : + justice and human development +} + +[33] para +.part: body +.parent: 32 +| Information, knowledge, and information-rich goods and tools play a +| significant role in economic opportunity and human development. +| ,{[pg 14]}, + +[34] para +.part: body +.parent: 32 +| From a more substantive and global perspective focused on human +| development, the freedom to use basic resources and capabilities +| allows improved participation in the production of information and +| information-dependent components of human development. +.has: bookindex +={ free software : + human development and justice ; + innovation : + human development +1 ; + open-source software : + human development and justice +} + +} + +@endnotes { + +% No endnotes in the Introduction chapter of this document. +% The Acknowledgments and Introduction sections shown above do not +% contain footnotes in the original text. Footnotes begin appearing +% in Chapter 2 and later chapters. + +} + +@bookindex { + +% Generated from ={ } entries throughout the body. +% The bookindex section aggregates all index terms across the document, +% sorted alphabetically, with OCN references collected. + +[0] bookindex +| access +| human development and justice: 9-11, 32-35 + +[0] bookindex +| accreditation +| as public good: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| aggregate effect of individual action: 16 + +[0] bookindex +| autonomy: 24-27 +| individual autonomy: 24-26 + +[0] bookindex +| Babel objection: 29, 31 + +[0] bookindex +| behavior +| motivation to produce: 19-21 + +[0] bookindex +| capabilities of individuals +| coordinated effects of individual actions: 14 + +[0] bookindex +| capital for production: 19-20 + +[0] bookindex +| centralization of communications +| decentralization: 29-32 + +[0] bookindex +| clusters in network topology: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| commercial model of communication: 14-15, 27, 29 +| shift away from: 29-31 + +[0] bookindex +| constraints of information production, monetary: 19 +| constraints of information production, physical: 14-15 + +[0] bookindex +| coordinated effects of individual actions: 14-16 + +[0] bookindex +| decentralization of communications: 29-32 + +[0] bookindex +| democratic societies: 22-37 +| autonomy: 24-27 +| justice and human development: 32-35 +| public sphere, shift from mass media: 28-32 +| shift from mass-media communications model: 29-32 + +[0] bookindex +| diversity +| human motivation: 19-20 +| motivation to produce: 19-20 + +[0] bookindex +| filtering +| as public good: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| free software: 17-18 +| human development and justice: 34 + +[0] bookindex +| human development and justice: 32-35 + +[0] bookindex +| human motivation: 19 + +[0] bookindex +| incentives to produce: 19 + +[0] bookindex +| individual capabilities and action +| coordinated effects of individual actions: 14-16 + +[0] bookindex +| industrial model of communication: 14-15, 27 +| shift away from: 29-32 + +[0] bookindex +| information economy: 9-64 +| democracy and liberalism: 22-37 +| emergence of: 12-21 + +[0] bookindex +| information flow: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| information overload and Babel objection: 29, 31 + +[0] bookindex +| information production +| physical constraints on: 14-15 + +[0] bookindex +| information production capital: 19-20 + +[0] bookindex +| innovation +| human development: 34-35 + +[0] bookindex +| institutional ecology of digital environment: 4, 14-15, 25-26 +| shift away from: 29-32 + +[0] bookindex +| justice and human development: 32-35 + +[0] bookindex +| liberal societies: 22-37 +| autonomy: 24-27 +| justice and human development: 32 + +[0] bookindex +| local clusters in network topology: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| loose affiliations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| Moglen, Eben: 18 + +[0] bookindex +| monetary constraints on information production: 19-21 + +[0] bookindex +| motivation to produce: 19-20 + +[0] bookindex +| networked information economy: 12-64 +| democracy and liberalism: 22-37 +| emergence of: 12-21 + +[0] bookindex +| networked public sphere: 29-32 +| loose affiliations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| nonmarket information producers: 13-17 + +[0] bookindex +| norms (social) +| loose affiliations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| open-source software: 17-18 +| human development and justice: 34 + +[0] bookindex +| peer production: 17 +| loose affiliations: 25 + +[0] bookindex +| physical capital for production: 19-21 +| physical constraints on information production: 13-15 + +[0] bookindex +| production capital: 19-21 +| production of information +| physical constraints on: 13-15 + +[0] bookindex +| public sphere: 29-32 +| loose affiliations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| regional clusters in network topology: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| regulation by social norms +| loose affiliations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| relevance filtering +| as public good: 31 + +[0] bookindex +| scope of loose relations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| social relations and norms +| loose affiliations: 25-26 + +[0] bookindex +| software, open-source: 17 + +[0] bookindex +| Stallman, Richard: 18 + +[0] bookindex +| traditional model of communication: 14, 27 +| shift away from: 29-32 + +[0] bookindex +| von Hippel, Eric: 18 + +} + diff --git a/format-specification.md b/format-specification.md index 64e445b..2814e33 100644 --- a/format-specification.md +++ b/format-specification.md @@ -364,7 +364,7 @@ SiSUAbstraction: ## File Extension -`.sda` (SiSU Document Abstraction) +`.ssp` (SiSU Document Abstraction) ## Relationship to Source Markup @@ -372,7 +372,7 @@ SiSUAbstraction: source.sst --> spineAbstraction() --> in-memory objects | v - document.sda (this format) + document.ssp (this format) | v load & reconstruct objects @@ -382,7 +382,7 @@ source.sst --> spineAbstraction() --> in-memory objects (HTML, EPUB, LaTeX, etc.) ``` -The `.sda` file captures the state AFTER parsing and abstraction but BEFORE +The `.ssp` file captures the state AFTER parsing and abstraction but BEFORE output generation. It is independent of any specific output format. ## Design Decisions -- cgit v1.2.3